Getting Started in the Moving Industry: Your Guide to Buying, Renting, or Leasing a Truck

Option 1:  Buying a Moving Truck

Deciding to buy a moving truck is a significant step that comes with both advantages and responsibilities. Owning your truck can provide long-term benefits for your business, including the ability to customize and brand it as part of your company's identity. However, it also requires careful consideration of the upfront investment and ongoing maintenance. Below, we’ve outlined the key pros and cons to help you evaluate if buying a truck aligns with your business goals.

Pros:

• Long-Term Savings: Owning a truck outright means you avoid monthly rental or lease payments.

• Equity: While trucks like most vehicles depreciate in value, owning one means you retain some residual value that can be recouped through resale or trade-in.

• Customization: You can brand the truck and equip it exactly as needed without any restrictions.

Cons:

• High Upfront Cost:  Purchasing a truck requires a significant initial investment. New 26-foot box trucks can range from $50,000 to over $100,000, depending on the make and model. Additionally, branding your truck with a custom wrap or painting can cost several thousand dollars or more, adding to the initial expense. Although, purchasing a used truck could be more affordable.  Of course, with used vehicles the older and more miles they have the more maintenance costs you will be spending on them and potential for downtime if something big goes wrong. 

• Maintenance Costs: You’re responsible for all repairs, which can add up over time.  Routine annual maintenance for one of our 26ft Box Trucks costs us between $3,000 - $5,000 and that is without the unexpected major repair. 

• Depreciation: The value of the truck decreases with age and mileage.

Best for: Established companies opening an additional location with consistent demand and enough capital to afford the upfront costs or a new company who has the capital and is ready to make that big investment. 

Option 2:  Short Term Renting a Moving Truck

Renting a moving truck can be an excellent choice for companies that need short-term solutions or additional capacity during busy seasons. It offers the flexibility to scale your operations without committing to a long-term investment, making it particularly useful for new businesses or those testing their market. However, while the upfront costs are lower, frequent rentals can add up over time. Below are the key pros and cons to consider.

Pros:

• Flexibility: Rent only when you need it, which is ideal for handling seasonal spikes. Some companies may only get 8-10 moves a month during the down season, but in the busy season could be doing 6 per week or more. 

• No Maintenance Costs: The rental company handles all maintenance and repairs.

• Lower Initial Investment: You pay only for the time you use the truck.
  

Cons:

• Higher Long-Term Costs: Renting frequently can become more expensive than buying or leasing. For example, U-Haul in Central Florida charges $49.95 per day for an in-town rate on a 26ft truck, with an additional $28 per day for their Safemove Plus insurance. On top of this, they charge $1.19 per mile, which can quickly add up depending on the distance of your move. Consider a job where the house is 20 miles from your starting point, 50 miles to the destination, and another 30 miles back to your base. This 100-mile trip would cost $119 in mileage alone, bringing your total for the day to approximately $196.95 (rental fee + insurance + mileage). If you were to book 15 similar jobs in a month, your total cost for rentals could exceed $2,950, not including fuel expenses, making it a costly option for frequent use.

• Limited Branding Opportunities: Rental trucks usually can’t be customized with your company logo. Do we really want to be pulling up to our customers homes in a U-Haul? 

• Availability Issues: Trucks may not always be available during peak seasons.

Best for: New businesses testing the market or companies needing extra capacity temporarily. 

Leasing a Moving Truck (Long Term Rental) 

This was one of our personal favorites with J&J Metro Moving and Storage.  Leasing a truck can be an attractive option for moving companies looking to balance costs and flexibility. This approach provides access to reliable, up-to-date equipment without the heavy financial burden of ownership. For businesses focused on growth, leasing offers predictable costs and less responsibility for maintenance. Below are the pros and cons to help you determine if leasing is the right fit for your needs.

Pros:

• Lower Monthly Payments: Leasing is often more affordable than buying outright.

• Up-to-Date Equipment: Lease agreements often include newer trucks with the latest features.

• Predictable Costs: Maintenance and repairs are typically included, streamlining your budgeting process. Plus, you’ll have peace of mind with emergency support. If your truck breaks down on the road, the provider will promptly deliver a replacement truck and handle the necessary repairs, ensuring minimal disruption to your operations. 

• Trusted Providers: Well-known companies like Enterprise, Penske, and Ryder, typically known for daily rentals, also offer flexible long-term rental and lease options tailored to meet business needs. 

• Branding Flexibility: Leasing agreements often allow you to customize trucks with wraps featuring your company branding, providing a professional appearance. However, permanent modifications like painting are typically not permitted.

Cons:

• No Long-Term Cost Savings: While leasing offers lower monthly payments compared to buying, the long-term cost may be higher since you don't retain ownership or build equity in the truck.

• Usage Restrictions: Leases may limit mileage or modifications.
  

• Contract Inflexibility: If your business needs change, you might find yourself locked into a lease agreement that no longer suits your operational requirements.

• Early Termination Fees: Ending a lease early can incur penalties.

Best for: Growing companies looking for reliable equipment without the commitment of ownership.

A Visual Comparison of Costs

To provide a clear picture of the financial differences between buying, renting, and leasing a truck, we’ve included a graph below. This visual representation highlights the monthly costs associated with each option, breaking down expenses like insurance, fuel, and maintenance. The data in this graph is based on a scenario of 15 days of rental use, which could vary depending on the number of jobs completed in a month. Remember, this is just an example, and your actual usage may result in different costs. Use this graph to compare the overall financial impact of each choice and better understand which aligns with your budget and business goals.

Key Considerations

When deciding between buying, renting, or leasing, ask yourself:

• • • • What’s your budget for upfront and ongoing costs?

      • How often will the truck be in use?

      • Do you want to brand the truck with your company logo?

      • How important is access to the latest equipment?

      • Are you prepared to handle maintenance costs and responsibilities?

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right option for your moving company depends on your current needs and future goals. Buying is ideal for established businesses, renting works well for short-term needs, and leasing offers a middle ground. Evaluate your budget, workload, and branding needs carefully before making a decision. The right choice will set your company up for success and help you serve your customers effectively.  

Disclaimer: While writing this post, we received some help from several moving companies. We have generalized the numbers to keep things a fair comparison.  Not all factors may pertain to your specific geographical demographic or situation. Different markets have differing costs for services like insurance and rental fees. It’s best to research your specific case before making any decisions. If you feel we missed the mark, let us know—we’d love your feedback!

Have you been thinking about Starting, Expanding or Growing Your Moving Company?  
Comment below and let us know. If you have any questions or there's anything we can assist with, we're happy to share